Actual student email: "I am totally confused. I do not understand paraphrasing. When I read something, I should try to change the sentence to my own words, right? Then use a citation. But when I use my own words, what if they still sound like something someone else wrote? (This is what scares me the most and it made me lose my focus on the paper)."
Sound familiar?
First, you will be delighted to learn that much of the confusion about paraphrasing comes from a simple misuse of words. You've been told many times that to paraphrase something is to "put it into your own words."
Well, that is not exactly the case.
To paraphrase something means to "put it into your own phrases," not your own words. If the source you are paraphrasing is describing the Great Mississippi River Flood of 1927, which covered 14% of the entire state of Louisiana, guess what? There is only one word for:
- Mississippi
- 1927
- Louisiana
- 14%
Obviously, paraphrasing isn't about "putting things in your own words" since you have no choice but to use those exact words. Paraphrasing is about putting things into your own phrases. Matter of fact, if you "put things into your own words" and don't change the basic sentence structure, you are still guilty of plagiarism. It is called "mosaic plagiarism." Here is what it looks like:
Original: "The Great Mississippi Flood of 1927--which covered large portions of Arkansas, Illinois, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, and Tennessee under 30 feet of water--is considered the most destructive river flood in United States history." (Source: “Fatal Flood,” http://www.pbs.org, 1999)
Incorrect Paraphrase (mosaic plagiarism): The Great Mississippi Flood of 1927--which inundated great patches of Arkansas, Illinois, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, and Tennessee under 10 meters of water--is often called the most devastating flood in American history (“Fatal Flood,” 1999).
See how 9 out of 20 words were changed (those not bolded)! And yet it's STILL PLAGIARISM! Even though a source citation is given.
Yes, lots of words were changed—
- covered -> inundated
- large portions -> great patches
- is considered -> is often called
- most destructive -> most devastating
- United States -> American
But the phrasing didn't change; therefore, the writer has committed plagiarism—even though there is a citation and even though nearly half the words were changed. However, the author’s sentence structure or phrasing is repeated. Guilty.
To avoid plagiarism when paraphrasing/summarizing:
- read the source closely
- put the source away, then
- rewrite the information from memory, phrasing it in your own way so that it fits into the paragraph you are writing and the point you're trying to make. When done, make sure that you compare your version to the original to check facts and to weed out any unintentional borrowing of phrases.
Let’s take a look at the correct way of doing it:
Original: "The Great Mississippi Flood of 1927--which covered large portions of Arkansas, Illinois, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, and Tennessee under 30 feet of water--is considered the most destructive river flood in United States history." (Source: “Fatal Flood,” http://www.pbs.org, 1999)
Good Paraphrase: In 1927, The Great Mississippi Flood drowned large portions of six states, including Louisiana, and is still remembered as the worst our country has ever known (“Fatal Flood,” 1999).
But wait! Many of the same words were used! Isn't this writer guilty of plagiarism?? Just look at all the words the writer “stole”:
- The Great Mississippi Flood
- 1927
- large portions
- Louisiana
No, the paraphrase is not plagiarized. The information from the source has been clearly translated into the writer's own phrasing. Repeating key words from a source is necessary and permissible so long as you create your own sentences for the words to be used in.
The only other change needed, just to be on the safe side, would be to revise "large portions" in the paraphrase to "massive areas." This shows the importance of the last step of paraphrasing: compare your version to the original to check facts and to weed out any phrasing ("large portions" is a phrase) that you unintentionally borrowed.
Paraphrase Exercise
Step 1: Find a brief section from a source that you could possibly use in the project you are working on.
Step 2: Quote the section in full, providing an in-text citation, as if you were using it in your paper.
Step 3: Paraphrase the section, providing an in-text citation, as if you were using it in your paper.
Step 4: Provide a reference citation to the source you are using.
Quotation (Author’s Exact Words)
Direct Quote in My Paper:
According to Raymond (2017), “Deaths from colon cancer occur twice as often in women as in men, but the media have made it seem that breast cancer is the number one killer of women" (p. 12). This misrepresentation is but one example of how the mass media distort our view women.
Please note:
- A signal phrase such as "According to ..." or "Raymond states, . . . " is used to introduce a direct quote. The quote is followed by the student author's own words that integrate the quote into the paragraph.
- The author’s last name together with (2009) constitute the in-text citation, which refers to the source listed alphabetically on the last page of your paper. Since the author's name ("Raymond") is mentioned in the sentence, it is not repeated inside the parentheses.
- Any direct wording from the original source must be in quotation marks.
- In-text citations use only the author's last name, not any initials.
Paraphrase (Rewritten in My Phrasing)
Paraphrase in My Paper:
Although twice as many women die from colon cancer as men, the media choose to focus on breast cancer as the main threat to women's health (Raymond, 2017, p. 12). This misrepresentation is but one example of how the mass media distort our view women.
Please note:
- Key words of the original have been repeated ("women," "media," "colon cancer," "breast cancer") but the quote has been successfully translated into the author's own phrasing.
- The in-text citation appears at end of the sentence with the author's name inside parentheses.
- The period for the sentence goes after the citation.
- The paraphrase is followed by the student author's own words that integrate the source material into the paragraph.
Reference Citation
Raymond, P. (2017). Colon cancer: Healthy women. Retrieved October 21, 2017 from http://www.healthywomen.org/condition/colon-cancer
Help with reference citation formats: Perhaps the best list of citation formats on the web can be found on this page of the UMGC Library: https://libguides.umgc.edu/apa-examples